مقارنة بين لوحتين Tyan مع معالج Xeon و كرتي شاشة Tachyon

[Doctor]

الأخوة الكرام ..
لقد قمت بتجميع كل المعلومات الأساسية عن مواصفات اللوحات الأم – المعالج – كرتي الشاشة .. الدراسة و المقارنة و الإختيار سوف تم على أساس أعمال المونتاج و الجرافيكس، بمعنى جودة كل قطعة في أداء أعمال المونتاج و الجرافيكس الإحترافية .. لذلك أرجوا من الجميع دراسة هذه المواصفات جيداً حسب خبراتهم و تجاربهم، بعد ذلك أطلب منكم التالي:
1. التعليق حول تلك المواصفات بالنسبة لأعمال المونتاج و الجرافيكس الإحترافية .. من ناحية الأفضل – العيوب – الملاحظات – جودة الأداء بالنسبة لأعمال المونتاج و الجرافيكس الإحترافية لكل قطعة على حدة .. و ذلك بالنسبة لكل لوحة أم و كرت شاشة.
2. إختيار اللوحة الأم الأفضل لأعمال المونتاج و الجرافيكس.
3. إختيار كرت الشاشة الأفضل بالنسبة لأعمال المونتاج و الجرافيكس .. إعتماداً على اللوحة الأم التي تم إختيارها في الخطوة السابقة، و من ثم مقارنته مع الكروت التالية بالنسبة لنفس اللوحة الأم التي تم إختيارها في الخطوة السابقة:
ATI Fire GL X1 - ATI AllWonder
4. إختيار أفضل لوحة أم مع أفضل كرت شاشة منها، بمعنى آخر ماهو كرت الشاشة الملائم لكل لوحة أم لأداء أعمال المونتاج و الجرافيكس.

Tiger i7500 (S2722)







Thunder i860 (S2603)





General Information:
Tiger i7500 (S2722):
Based on Intel®'s E7500 chipset, the Tiger i7500 platform supports two Xeon™ processors, Hyper-Threading, remote management of IPMI functions through optional SMDC (Server Management Daughter Card), is compatible with both ATX12V and EPS12V power supplies. The Tiger i7500 also offers an ATX form factor for a variety of environments, Gigabit Ethernet and Fast Ethernet ports for flexible networking, and onboard ATI RAGE XL VGA - all providing a powerful and versatile solution for your server needs.

Thunder i860 (S2603):
Designed for the Intel Xeon processor with Netburst microarchitecture, Tyan's Thunder i860 provides groundbreaking performance for advanced workstation applications. This high-performance system board supports two Intel Xeon processors and is based on their i860 chipset, which supports a 400MHz system bus and up to 4GB of Rambus memory. These features, combined with integrated 10/100 LAN connectivity and optional SCSI support, make Thunder i860 the ideal platform for digital video editing, CAD, 3D modeling, financial analysis and more.

Processor:
Tiger i7500 (S2722):
• Dual mPGA603 ZIF sockets
• Supports up to two Intel® Xeon™ processors with 512KB of integrated L2 cache
• Onboard VRM (VRM 9.1 spec)
• Front-Side Bus support for 400MHz

Thunder i860 (S2603):
• Dual PGA603 ZIF sockets
• Supports up to two Intel® Xeon™ processors
• Two onboard VRMs
• Front-Side Bus support for 400MHz

Chipset:
Tiger i7500 (S2722):
• Intel® E7500 server chipset
• MCH + ICH3 + P64H2 + FWH
• Intel® P64H2 supports two PCI (-X) buses
• Winbond™ W83627HF Super I/O chip
• Winbond™ W83782D hardware monitoring chip

Thunder i860 (S2603):
• Intel® 860 chipset
• 82860 North Bridge, 82801BA I/O Controller Hub, 82802AB Firmware Hub and 82806AA PCI 64 Hub

Memory:
Tiger i7500 (S2722):
• Four 184-pin 2.5V DDR DIMM sockets
• Dual channel memory bus
• Supports up to 8GB of Registered DDR200
• Supports Registered memory only
• Supports ECC type memory modules

Thunder i860 (S2603):
• Eight 184-pin RIMM sockets
• Dual channel memory bus
• Supports up to 4GB of PC800 Rambus memory
• Memory Expansion Card (MEC) design

Expansion Slots:
Tiger i7500 (S2722):
• Three independent PCI (-X) buses
• Two 64-bit 133/100/66MHz (3.3V) PCI-X slots
• One 32-bit 33MHz (5V) PCI slot
• Total of three usable slots

Thunder i860 (S2603):
• One AGP Pro slot; also supports 4x
• Two 64-bit 66MHz (3.3-volt) and three 32-bit
• 33MHz (5-volt) PCI slots
• Total of six usable slots

Integrated I/O:
Tiger i7500 (S2722):
• One floppy connector supports up to two drives
• Two 9-pin serial ports (one connector and one header)
• One 25-pin ECP/EPP/SPP parallel header (opt.)
• Four USB 1.1 ports (two rear, two via header)
• PS/2 keyboard and mouse connectors

Thunder i860 (S2603):
• One floppy connector supports up to two drives
• Two 9-pin 16550-based serial ports
• One 25-pin ECP/EPP/SPP parallel header
• Two USB ports
• PS/2 keyboard and mouse ports

Integrated PCI IDE:
Tiger i7500 (S2722):
• Provides two PCI bus master channels for up to four Enhanced IDE (EIDE) devices
• Support for ATA-100/66/33 IDE drives and ATAPI-compliant devices

Thunder i860 (S2603):
• Dual-channel master mode
• Support up to four Enhanced IDE devices
• Support for ATA-100/66/33 IDE and ATAPI-compliant devices

Integrated LAN Controllers:
Tiger i7500 (S2722):
• Intel® 82545EM Gigabit Ethernet controller (opt.)
- One RJ-45 LAN connector with LEDs
- Connected to PCI-X bus
• Intel® 82551QM Fast Ethernet controller
- One RJ-45 LAN connector with LEDs

Thunder i860 (S2603):
• Intel® 82550EY LAN controller
• 10/100Mbps data transfer rate

Integrated Video:
Tiger i7500 (S2722):
• ATI Rage™ XL PCI graphics controller
• 8MB of video memory

Thunder i860 (S2603):
Non

Integrated Audio:
Tiger i7500 (S2722):
Non

Thunder i860 (S2603):
• Analog Devices AD1885 chipset
• AC'97 codec
• Line-in, Line-out and Mice ports

BIOS:
Tiger i7500 (S2722):
• AMI BIOS 8.0 on 4Mbit Flash ROM
• LAN remote boot (PXE) and SMBIOS v2.3
• BIOS Boot Specification v3.1 (BBS) support
• Auto configuration of IDE hard drive types

Thunder i860 (S2603):
• Phoenix ™ BIOS on 4Mb Flash ROM
• Supports APM v1.2 and ACPI v1.0
• User settings for hardware monitoring
• Auto configuration of IDE hard drive types
• Multiple boot options; DMI 2.0 compliant

Integrated SCSI:
Tiger i7500 (S2722):
Non

Thunder i860 (S2603):
• LSI SYM53C1010R controller
• Dual-channel Ultra160 SCSI support160MB/sec max. Data throughput per channel
• Supports up to 15 LVD SCSI devices per channel
- Channel A: 68-pin connector
- Channel B: 68-pin connector


Intel® Xeon™ processor:
Available speeds:
• 2.80GHz, 2.66GHz, 2.40GHz, 2GHz
Server Chipset:
• Intel® E7501 Chipset
Features:
• Dual-processor enabled
• Hyper-Threading Technology
• Intel® NetBurst™ microarchitecture
• Rapid Execution Engine
• Streaming SIMD Extensions 2 (SSE2)
• Advanced dynamic execution
Cache:
• Level 1: Execution Trace cache
• Level 2: 512KB Advanced Transfer cache
RAM:
• Dual Channel DDR
I/O Bandwidth:
• Up to 4.3 GB/sec
System Bus Frequency:
• 533 MHz System Bus





Tachyon G9000 PRO





Tachyon G9700 PRO




General Information:
Tachyon G9000 PRO:
The Tachyon G9000 PRO ushers in new levels of performance and value for power-users, digital content creators, and 3D gaming enthusiasts. Designed around the ATI® RADEON™ 9000 PRO visual processing unit (VPU), the Tachyon G9000 PRO features four parallel, highly optimized rendering pipelines, providing enhanced performance normally found on more expensive graphics cards. Tachyon G9000 PRO users also get 64MB of DDR memory, best-in-class 3D gaming, complex and realistic lighting effects, DirectX® 8.1 support, dual-display support, and an industry-leading software suite.

Tachyon G9700 PRO:
The Tachyon G9700 PRO is the new weapon of choice for the elite gamer, enthusiast, power user, and graphics developer! Featuring the ATI ® RADEON™ 9700 PRO visual processing unit (VPU), the first processor to fully support DirectX 9.0 and OpenGL 1.3 functionality, the Tachyon G9700 PRO graphics card equips your imagination with sophisticated real-time rendering that rivals that of cinematic feature films. Tachyon G9700 PRO users also benefit from 128MB of DDR memory, best-in-class 3D gaming, complex and realistic lighting effects, dual-display support, and an industry-leading software suite.
The Tachyon G9700 PRO is the only RADEON 9700 PRO-based graphics card on the market with hardware monitoring! The Tachyon Graphics Monitor is a user-friendly system monitoring utility that allows the user to monitor and regulate fan, voltage, and temperature. The Tachyon G9700 PRO is the ultimate addition to any gaming machine. The Tachyon G9700 PRO fully supports Microsoft's DirectX 9 technology for the most heart pounding, chest thumping gaming experience.

Specifications:
Tachyon G9000 PRO:
• ATI® RADEON™ 9000 PRO 128-bit VPU; 275MHz engine
• 64MB DDR memory; 550MHz DDR
• VGA, DVI-I, and S-Video connectors
• Optimized for DirectX® 8/8.1 and OpenGL™ 1.3
• HYDRAVISION™ multi-monitor support; dual independent 400MHz DACs
• AGP 4x/2x compatible

Tachyon G9700 PRO:
• ATI® RADEON™ 9700 PRO 256-bit VPU, 325MHz engine
• Up to 128MB ultra high-speed DDR memory; 620MHz DDR
• 128-bit floating-point precision color
• Optimized for DirectX® 9 and OpenGL™ 1.3
• 6X Full-Scene Anti-Aliasing
• HYDRAVISION™ multi-display; dual independent 400MHz 10-bit DACs
• AGP 8x/4x/2x compatible
• Featuring new TGM with over clocking utility and hardware monitoring

Visual Processing Unit:
Tachyon G9000 PRO:
- ATI RADEON 9000 PRO
- 275MHz core frequency

Tachyon G9700 PRO:
- ATI RADEON 9700 PRO
- 325MHz core frequency

Onboard Frame Buffer:
Tachyon G9000 PRO:
- 64MB DDR SDRAM
- 550 MHz DDR frequencies

Tachyon G9700 PRO:
- 128MB DDR SDRAM
- 620 MHz DDR frequencies

Connections:
Tachyon G9000 PRO:
- DB15 VGA Analog out
- DVI-I Digital out
- TV Analog out
. . . S-Video
. . . Composite

Tachyon G9700 PRO:
- DB15 VGA Analog out
- DVI-I Digital out
- TV Analog out
. . . S-Video
. . , Composite

Interface:
Tachyon G9000 PRO:
- AGP 4X, 2X
- Universal AGP
- Intel/AMD platform
- Microsoft Windows

Tachyon G9700 PRO:
- AGP 8X, 4X, 2X
- Universal AGP
- Intel/AMD platform
- Microsoft Windows

[الوليد]

بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم

ليس هناك جدوى من مقارنة هاتين اللوحتين ببعض اخى. لوحة i7500 لاتدعم شق AGP ولهذا فانك لن تستطيع ان تركب كرت شاشة منفصل عليها. الاولى لك اخى ان تجعل المقارنة مع لوحة i7505 بدلا من i7500.

بالنسبة لكروت الشاشة، فانه لايوجد وجه للمقارنة بين 9000 و 9700. كرت 9700 هو الافضل بدون اى منازع.